Skip to content

How to use used-car market analysis in a dealer network: from benchmarking sites to regular reviews

How to benchmark sites against their local market, decide on stock transfers and central buying, enter a new country and set up regular reviews.

Two dealership managers reviewing a report in a showroom
AI-generated illustrative photograph.
In this article

Key findings

  • Benchmark each site against its local market in the same segment first, and only then against other sites. Otherwise differences in competition and stock mix look like differences in team performance.
  • Moving a car to another site only pays off when a higher price or a faster sale at the destination covers transport, preparation and the days the car is off sale.
  • A single stock mix for every country does not work. Among used all-wheel-drive cars whose listings were removed between January and September 2026, 23.9% were electrified in Austria, but only 8.8% in Poland.
  • A three-tier rhythm works well for networks: individual cars every week, buying limits and stock allocation every month, the site plan once a quarter.

A dealer group knows every car from its own system: what it paid, how long the car has been in stock and what it sold for. What it cannot see is what competitors in the same town have for sale, at what price and how quickly those cars disappear. When cars sell slowly at one site, internal data cannot tell whether the problem lies with the site or with the market. Used-car market analysis makes exactly that distinction. It is only worthwhile, however, if it actually changes buying, the allocation of cars across sites and pricing.

1. Benchmark each site against its market

Take a site where family SUVs are selling slowly. There are two possible causes. Either its cars are priced above comparable offers in the area, in which case adjusting the price or the listing will help. Or so many SUVs are on offer in the region that local demand cannot absorb them, and buying needs to change. A site's own sales figures cannot tell these apart; a comparison with local supply can.

The local market is better defined by where customers come from than by administrative boundaries. For mainstream used cars, a site competes mainly with its immediate surroundings, while buyers travel further for rarer cars. Comparisons must be made between cars that are similar in make, model, age, mileage, powertrain, gearbox and equipment. The average price of the whole stock says nothing when one site sells nearly new cars and another sells ten-year-old ones.

For each site and segment, management only needs to track three things: what share of local supply the site accounts for, where its prices sit against comparable cars and how many enquiries each car generates. Listings data shows supply as it appears on the portals, including cars listed more than once or offered by several sites. Comparing sites therefore only makes sense when the figures for all of them are calculated from the same portals and by the same rules.

Stock Report from Carsdata speeds up this work. It compares a site's stock with the market, recommends a price for each car and flags the cars that need action, for example because of equipment missing from the listing, weak photos or the wrong category. All sites are then assessed by the same yardstick.

2. Allocate and transfer cars according to the market

The place where a car is bought in or returned from a lease is not necessarily where it will sell best. That is why it pays to decide on the destination site at the moment of purchase. Large groups do this centrally: according to the trade press, the German group Alphartis decides for each car whether it goes to retail or to the trade. Aramis Group offers cars from Italy in the group's other countries through an internal marketplace.

Transfers are not a cure-all, though. If a car is priced above comparable offers, moving it simply relocates the problem, and the right first step is to adjust the price. If a car is waiting for preparation, a transfer only prolongs the wait. And if a site gets enquiries but fails to close deals, the cause usually lies in the car's condition or in how customers are handled. A transfer helps in one case only: the price is in line with the market, local demand is weak, and another site is selling well in the same segment and is short of stock. Even then, the expected price at the destination must cover transport, additional preparation and the days off sale, and for a cross-border transfer also registration and the tax treatment.

Electrified all-wheel-drive cars show how much markets differ. The table gives the share of electric cars, full hybrids and plug-in hybrids among used all-wheel-drive passenger cars whose listings were removed from the main listing portals between January and September 2026 (cars with more than 6,000 km on the clock):

Country Share of electric and hybrid cars among used all-wheel-drive cars
Austria 23.9%
Germany 15.7%
Italy 15.2%
Romania 14.1%
Czech Republic 12.3%
Slovakia 10.9%
Poland 8.8%

Since 2023, this share has risen by a factor of 1.4 to 4.1, depending on the country. Carvago published the data in a press release (in Czech), and it is based on EAG Group data, which also powers Carsdata products. For a network operating in several countries, the conclusion is simple: an all-wheel-drive stock mix built around Austrian supply would not fit Poland. A removed listing is only a rough proxy for a sale, so decisions on where to send a car must also take into account enquiries and sales at the destination site. What sells in each country is covered in more detail in the article European used car market trends.

3. Buy centrally to a brief for each segment

Central buying needs more from the sites than a list of favourite models. For each segment, it should have a clear brief:

  • the destination site the car will go to;
  • the required age, mileage, powertrain, gearbox and equipment;
  • how many similar cars the network already has, including cars in transit and in preparation;
  • the maximum purchase price after transport and preparation costs;
  • the condition under which buying stops.

The last point is the most important. A segment with a good sales record tempts buyers into further purchases, but if stock is currently building up in it, every additional similar car makes the situation worse.

For the search itself, there is Sourcing from Carsdata. It brings offers from European listing portals and auctions into one search and, for each car, estimates the selling price in the dealer's market, the margin after the dealer's transport and preparation costs, the model's liquidity and the days on display. Buyers can then choose cars according to the destination site's market, not just by a low purchase price.

4. Entering a new region or country

Stock that works in one country cannot simply be copied to another. A new site needs its own business case built on data from the target market: what supply customers there already have, which segments sell quickly and how the site will stand out. A small number of competing listings may signal an opportunity, but also weak demand. Time on market is the deciding factor: when cars in a segment disappear quickly, demand exceeds supply.

Sourcing stock needs checking too. Used cars up to three years old come from new cars sold a few years earlier, and where few were sold, they will be in short supply. The French statistical office SDES explains the limited supply of younger used cars in exactly this way, pointing to the low number of new cars put on the road since 2020. A site in such a market will more often have to bring in stock from the network's other countries, which both pricing and logistics must allow for. It is safer to start with a narrower range and widen it in line with actual sales.

5. Who reviews the data and how often

The network needs one owner of the shared definitions and the overview, usually a central head of used cars working with an analyst. Site managers are responsible for action on individual cars, the buying team for the future stock mix, and finance for correctly allocated costs.

Frequency Who What is discussed Outcome
Weekly Site manager and central head of used cars Cars attracting no interest, long preparation times, price deviations, transfers Action list with an owner and a deadline
Monthly Used-car management, buying, sites, finance Sales, margins, stock and position against the local market Adjusted buying limits and stock allocation
Quarterly Group management Segments, site capacity, new markets Revised sales and buying plan

The monthly overview should show, for each site and segment, days in stock, stock turn, margin after costs, price position against the market and the number of enquiries per car. For stock age, bands shared across the whole network work well, for example up to 30, 31–60, 61–90 and over 90 days. How to handle cars in the last band is covered in the article Aged used car stock. Track the value of the cars as well as their number, because a few expensive, slow-selling cars can tie up more money than dozens of cheap used cars. That is why the Dutch dealer association BOVAG tracks the number of used cars in stock, their value and the holding period in its barometer.

For each transfer or repricing, it is enough to record the reason, the expected outcome and a review date. At the next meeting, it is then immediately clear what worked and what is worth repeating at other sites.

Carsdata connects market, stock and buying

Network management needs to see the whole market in which its sites buy and sell, not a single portal. Carsdata brings used-car supply from many European portals and auctions together into one dataset with standardised vehicle data.

  • Market Data shows how supply, prices, days on market and estimated sales are developing in a chosen market and segment. Management can then compare site results with how the market they operate in is moving.
  • Stock Report compares each site's stock with the market, recommends prices and flags the cars that need action. It also shows stock value and days in stock across the whole network.
  • Sourcing combines the search for cars on European portals and auctions with estimates of the selling price, margin and model liquidity in the destination site's market.

The data is available in a web platform, through an API and in exports. Carsdata also has a native connection to Omnetic DMS, so market data can be fed into the system the group already works with.

Book a Carsdata demo and see the data for the markets where your sites operate.

FAQ

What should you do when there are few comparable cars in the region?

Widen the area first, and only then the age or mileage range. Keep powertrain and gearbox fixed, because they significantly change the pool of buyers. Then treat the result as a rougher guide.

How do you compare sites when the market fluctuates with the seasons?

Seasonality affects both the site and its market, so share of supply and price position largely cancel it out. Compare absolute figures such as sales or days in stock year on year for the same months.

Should a site manager's pay be linked to the site's share of local supply?

Not on its own. Share can be increased simply by adding stock, at the cost of tied-up capital. For incentives, a combination of the site's financial result, holding period and stock quality works better.

Sources

  1. https://blog.carvago.com/ctyrkolky-se-elektrifikuji-podil-elektromobilu-a-hybridu-se-v-sesti-zemich-za-tri-roky-vice-nez-zdvojnasobil/
  2. https://www.autohaus.de/nachrichten/autohandel/b2b-remarketing-mit-system-3781364
  3. https://aramis.group/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/press-release-aramis-group-2025-annual-results.pdf
  4. https://www.statistiques.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/immatriculations-de-voitures-en-2025-le-marche-du-neuf-baisse-celui-de-loccasion-resiste?dossier=1347&rubrique=
  5. https://mijn.bovag.nl/actueel/nieuws/winst-autodealers-herstelt-na-sterk-tweede-kwartaal
← All articles