Official registration statistics or listings? How to choose and combine used-car market data sources
What registration statistics, listings, B2B auctions, dealer systems and surveys show, how fast they arrive and how to combine them for decisions.

In this article
Key findings
- Official registration statistics confirm that a car has changed owner or registered keeper, but they arrive with a delay, contain no prices and are published by only some countries. Listings show supply and prices continuously, but sales can only be estimated from them.
- Even where they are published, these statistics are not comparable without adjustment: Germany counts changes of keeper, Italy records transfers to dealers separately, and France and Austria also include imported used cars.
- B2B auctions add wholesale prices, the dealer system adds the actual margin and surveys add buyer motivation. None of these sources is sufficient on its own.
- The most revealing moments come when sources diverge. If supply is growing while your sales stall, registration statistics will show whether the market is weakening or just your own offer.
Companies in the used-car trade know their own figures down to the last car. They learn about the market around them from a range of sources: registration statistics, listings, auctions and surveys. Each of these, however, captures a different moment in the transaction, from the publication of an offer to the entry in the register, and each comes with a different delay. Mistakes arise mainly when these sources are mixed as if they measured the same thing.
Overview of sources
| Source | What it shows | When it is available | Main limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Registration statistics | Recorded changes of owner or keeper, by country and also by brand, fuel or region | After the period has closed; monthly in Germany | No prices; each country counts differently and many do not publish them |
| Listings | Cars on offer, their specifications, prices and time on offer | Continuously | Shows supply, not sales; the same car may be listed more than once |
| B2B auctions | Wholesale supply and prices of completed deals | Immediately after the auction closes | Results depend on the mix of sellers and the auction rules |
| Dealer system | Purchasing, preparation, stock, actual selling price and margin | Instantly | Detailed picture of your own business, but not of the market |
| Surveys | Motivation and behaviour of buyers and sellers | Months later | Coarse breakdowns; depends on the questions and the sample |
For day-to-day work, the foundation is listings, your own data and, where they exist, registration statistics. Auctions and surveys answer the questions this trio cannot.
Registration statistics: where they exist and what they count
Official change-of-ownership statistics are reliable proof that a car really has changed hands. Only some countries publish them regularly, typically Germany, Italy, France and Austria. Elsewhere, for example in the Czech Republic, the publicly available statistics mainly cover registrations of new cars and imported used cars, not changes of ownership within the country. And even where such statistics exist, they differ in what they count as part of the used-car market:
| Country | What the statistics include | What to watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Germany | The KBA publishes changes of keeper monthly, including by brand, fuel and federal state | A change of keeper does not necessarily mean a sale to an end customer |
| Italy | ACI records transfers to dealers (minivolture) separately | Unless they are separated out, a single sale can be counted twice |
| France | SDES also includes first registrations of imported used cars and changes of long-term lessee | The total covers more types of event than domestic sales |
| Austria | Statistik Austria also includes cars previously registered abroad | Imports push the numbers up even when domestic trade is flat |
Adding them up therefore makes no sense. It is better to follow each country separately and compare the pace of change. Registrations also have predictive value: anyone who follows new-car and fleet sales knows several years in advance which nearly new used cars will be in short supply. The French statistical office SDES explains the limited supply of younger used cars in this way, pointing to the low number of new cars since 2020. What registration statistics cannot tell you is what a car sold for and how long it stood unsold. And in countries that do not publish changes of ownership, listings are practically the only continuous picture of the whole used-car market.
Listings: supply in real time
Listings are the only source that shows continuously what is available on the market and at what price. They can be read in three ways. Active listings show what customers are comparing your cars with right now. New listings show what is being added to supply. And removed listings serve as a rough proxy for sales, because a listing usually disappears when the car is sold.
They do have their limitations, though. The same car may be offered by several sites, appear on several portals, or be removed and relisted by the seller. The number of listings therefore does not equal the number of cars. And a listing can disappear without a sale, so its removal does not confirm a change of ownership.
A well-defined listings analysis therefore always states what it is based on. Carvago's press releases on the electrification of all-wheel-drive cars (in Czech) and on Chinese brands (in Czech), for example, which are built on EAG Group data that also powers Carsdata products, specify exactly: listings of used passenger cars with more than 6,000 km on the main portals in seven countries, the period covered and whether the figures refer to new or removed listings. They also point out explicitly that the data does not distinguish between generations or model years.
An overview of supply, prices and time on market for a specific country and segment is provided by Market Data from Carsdata.
Auctions, dealer systems and surveys
B2B auctions show what the trade is willing to pay for a car. They are useful mainly for remarketing and for deciding whether to sell a car at retail or to another dealer, a decision large groups take centrally. Only completed deals should be counted, not starting prices or unsuccessful auctions. Wholesale price indices also often come from a single platform, so they reflect its vehicle mix rather than the whole market. And the gap between wholesale and retail prices is not all margin: it has to pay for preparation, selling and risk.
The dealer system is the only source that knows the actual selling price and margin. The time from purchase to sale it records, however, also includes preparation, so it is longer than the time a car spends listed. Trade barometers combine data from multiple dealers; the Dutch dealer association BOVAG, for example, uses its barometer to track the number, value and holding period of used cars in stock. Such barometers show how a business compares with the sector, but not with the competition in its own town.
Surveys explain why and how people buy cars. The French household budget survey, for example, also asks whether the household sold a car in the past year, so it captures private sales without a listing as well. Surveys are not suitable for continuous market monitoring, though, because the results arrive late.
How to combine sources
A register entry, a listing and an invoice are different records, and until you link them, they do not necessarily describe the same transaction. In a combined report, it must therefore be clear for every figure where it comes from and what it counts: listings, cars, recorded changes or completed sales.
| Situation | Which sources to combine | What the business learns |
|---|---|---|
| A dealer is repricing cars in stock | Listings plus its own selling prices and holding periods | Whether competitors' prices have moved or the problem lies in its own offer |
| A leasing company is selling returned cars | Listings, B2B auction results and its own remarketing data | What a car would fetch at retail and what at auction |
| A bank is monitoring financed cars | Market supply, registrations and proceeds from the sale of collateral | Whether lower recoveries reflect the market or the make-up of its own portfolio |
| An importer is monitoring its brand | Listings, new-car registrations and dealer network data | When today's new cars will reach the market as used cars and how the network is performing against the market |
The most valuable insights usually come when sources diverge. When supply in a segment is growing while your sales stall, listings alone cannot tell you whether demand is weakening. In countries that publish registration statistics, they settle the question: if changes of ownership in the segment keep rising, the problem more likely lies in your offer or your price; if they are falling too, the market is changing. Elsewhere, a comparison with competitors' removed listings helps. How to build this view into the management of a network of sites is described in the article How to use used-car market analysis in a dealer network, and how to read a brand's presence in supply in the article Brand share of the used-car market.
Three mistakes come up again and again. An added portal or a new group of sellers increases the captured supply and looks like market growth. The average price changes with the vehicle mix even when comparable cars are not getting more expensive; this is discussed in detail in the article How to track used car prices. And the most recent data includes a period that is not yet closed, in which some changes have yet to be recorded.
Carsdata: market data alongside your own figures
Carsdata collects used-car listings and auction offers from European portals and standardises the vehicle data into one dataset. Analysts therefore do not have to convert the formats and code lists of individual portals. Carsdata shows active supply as it appears on the portals. In the history of removed listings, however, it links a car that a seller removed and relisted on the same portal, so that it is not counted twice there.
Market Data uses this data to show supply, prices, days on market, estimated sales and dealer network performance in dashboards, recurring reports and data feeds. It estimates sold cars from the listing lifecycle, and reports always make clear that this is an estimate, not a record of sales.
The data is available in a web platform, through an API and in exports. Banks, leasing companies and importers can also receive it as custom dashboards and reports. Dealer groups can use the native connection between Carsdata and Omnetic DMS, which brings market data together with their own stock and sales data.
A Carsdata demo will show what a market overview would look like for your market and segment.
FAQ
Do I need the VIN of every car for market analysis?
Not for tracking supply by country, age or powertrain. But if you want to link a market record to a specific car in your own stock or portfolio, this cannot be done reliably without the VIN.
How much history do I need?
For seasonal comparisons, you need the same period in previous years, not just the previous month. To spot shifts in the powertrain or age mix of supply, it is best to have at least two to three years of data.
Can listings tell me the actual selling price?
No. The last price in a listing is an asking price, and buyers often negotiate a discount. Listings are good enough for estimating the market price and how it develops; actual prices come only from your own sales or completed auction deals.
Sources
- https://www.govdata.de/suche/daten/fz-9-2025-besitzumschreibungen-von-kraftfahrzeugen-und-kraftfahrzeuganhangern
- https://www.aci.it/mobilita/mercato-automobilistico/
- https://www.statistiques.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/media/8981/download?inline=
- https://www.statistiques.developpement-durable.gouv.fr/immatriculations-de-voitures-en-2025-le-marche-du-neuf-baisse-celui-de-loccasion-resiste?dossier=1347&rubrique=
- https://www.statistik.at/fileadmin/announcement/2024/07/20240712KfzGebrauchtzulassungenHalbjahr12024.pdf
- https://mijn.bovag.nl/actueel/nieuws/winst-autodealers-herstelt-na-sterk-tweede-kwartaal
- https://www.autohaus.de/nachrichten/autohandel/b2b-remarketing-mit-system-3781364
- https://www.insee.fr/fr/information/7652980
- https://blog.carvago.com/ctyrkolky-se-elektrifikuji-podil-elektromobilu-a-hybridu-se-v-sesti-zemich-za-tri-roky-vice-nez-zdvojnasobil/
- https://blog.carvago.com/cinske-znacky-na-trhu-ojetin-v-sesti-ze-sedmi-zemi-zatim-pod-jednim-procentem-jejich-podil-se-vsak-rok-co-rok-zhruba-zdvojnasobuje-ukazuje-analyza-carvago/
- https://www.auto1-group.com/index/

